CJ Bloor Property Consultants0333 577 9556Call the officeGet a fixed quoteGet a quote
Advice

Selling for More or Less Than the Probate Value: IHT38, Capital Gains and HMRC Checks

What happens when an inherited home sells for more or less than its probate value: when HMRC uses the sale price, how capital gains tax works on the difference, claiming inheritance tax back on form IHT38 and its traps, and how the Valuation Office checks the figures.

Close-up of weathered tombstones in an overgrown historical cemetery during autumn.

Executors often value the home for probate, wait for the grant, put it on the market and then find that the sale price is nowhere near the probate figure. Sometimes it is well above, because the market has moved or a neighbour wanted the garden. Sometimes it is well below, because the house sat empty through a winter, a survey turned up a problem, or prices fell.

Either way, the same questions follow. Was the probate value wrong? Does HMRC want more tax? Can we claim some back? This guide explains what usually happens in each direction, how HMRC and the Valuation Office check the figures, and why the original valuation matters so much when they do. It covers England and Wales. It is not tax advice, and the solicitor or accountant handling the estate will advise on your own case.

Two figures, two questions

The probate value answers one question: what would the home have fetched on the open market on the day the person died? That is the test in section 160 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984, and it is the figure that goes on the inheritance tax forms.

The sale price answers a different one: what did a buyer actually pay, on the day contracts were exchanged, for the home as it was then?

The two can differ for perfectly good reasons:

  • Time. Probate and a sale can take a year or more. Prices move in that time, in both directions.
  • Condition. An empty home deteriorates. A burst pipe, a break-in or a damp winter can take thousands off. Equally, executors sometimes clear, decorate or repair before selling.
  • The buyer. A neighbour who wants the land, a developer who sees a plot, or a cash buyer looking for a quick deal can each pay more or less than the open market would.
  • The marketing. A quick auction, a sale to the first offer, or a long campaign with a good agent can produce different results for the same home.

None of that means the probate value was wrong. But when the gap is large, someone will want it explained, and the explanation starts with how the probate figure was reached.

Chris Bloor, on site

I measure homes for probate as they stood on the day of death, not as they show on the day of my visit. That matters more than people expect. I looked at a terrace that had stood empty through two winters, and the damp and the stripped kitchen had nothing to do with its value when the owner died. So I note the condition on the day, and I write down what I think it was before. When the sale later comes in low, that record is what explains the gap, rather than leaving the executors to argue it from memory.

Chris Bloor

If the home sells for more

Soon after the death, where inheritance tax is due

A sale to an unconnected buyer on the open market, shortly after the death, is often the best evidence there is of the home's value at the date of death. HMRC knows this. Schedule IHT405, the page of the inheritance tax account that lists any house, asks whether the property has been sold or will be sold within 12 months of the death, and whether the executors want to use the sale price as the date-of-death value.

HMRC's internal manual explains how this plays out. If the executors are willing to adopt the gross sale price, and the sale was at full value and not to a connected person, the case often does not need to go to the Valuation Office at all. If a sale comes to light after the Valuation Office has reported, HMRC can accept a higher value based on it.

So where the estate owes inheritance tax, a sale soon after the death for noticeably more is likely to lead to a higher value and more tax, charged at 40% on the difference, with interest. GOV.UK also says executors must tell HMRC about a change in the value of land or buildings, normally on a corrective account, before the values are final or within 18 months of the death, whichever is sooner. Your solicitor will advise whether one is needed.

The further the sale is from the date of death, the weaker that link becomes. A sale two years later, after the market has risen, is not good evidence of what the home was worth on the day of death, and a valuation that shows the sales evidence from that time is what demonstrates it.

Where no inheritance tax turns on the value

Where the estate owes no inheritance tax, because it is below its nil-rate bands or passes to a surviving spouse or charity, the higher sale price does not usually change any inheritance tax. It becomes a capital gains tax question instead.

Whoever sells, the executors or the beneficiary who inherited, is treated as having acquired the home at its market value at the date of death. The gain is broadly the sale price less that value and the costs of buying and selling.

An illustration, not real figures, for a home sold by the executors 14 months after the death:

StepAmount
Sale price£330,000
Less value at date of death£300,000
Less agent's and legal fees on the sale£6,000
Gain£24,000
Less executors' annual exempt amount£3,000
Taxable gain£21,000
Tax at 24%£5,040

Executors pay capital gains tax at 24% on disposals from 30 October 2024, and can use an annual exempt amount in the tax year of death and the two following years. Gains on UK homes normally have to be reported and the tax paid within 60 days of completion. Where a beneficiary sells instead, their own allowance and rates apply, and where a beneficiary lived in the home as their main residence, relief may cut the gain. Our guide to capital gains tax valuations covers the valuation side of that in more detail, and where no figure was ever prepared at the time, a retrospective valuation for capital gains tax can rebuild one.

There is a catch here that is easy to miss. HMRC's capital gains manual explains that where the value made no difference to the inheritance tax, it has not been "ascertained", so it is not fixed for capital gains tax. If the gain looks large, HMRC can question the date-of-death value itself. An estate agent's figure with no evidence behind it is hard to defend at that point. A report that sets out the comparable sales from the time is not.

If the home sells for less

Loss on sale of land relief, form IHT38

Where the estate paid inheritance tax and the executors sell the home for less than its probate value, they may be able to replace the probate value with the sale price and reclaim the tax on the difference. The claim is made on form IHT38 under sections 190 to 198 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984.

The main conditions, from the Act and HMRC's manual:

  • Who claims. The person liable for the tax, which is normally the executors. It is not usually available where the home has already been passed to a beneficiary who then sells.
  • When the sale happens. Sales within three years of the death count. Sales in the fourth year count only if they are at a loss.
  • When to claim. HMRC's manual says the claim must be made within four years after the end of the three-year period.
  • A minimum loss. No relief where the difference is less than £1,000 or 5% of the date-of-death value, whichever is lower.
  • Tax must have been paid. If no inheritance tax was due, there is nothing to reclaim.

An illustration, not real figures, for an estate already well above its nil-rate bands:

StepAmount
Probate value of the home£300,000
Gross sale price, 18 months after the death£270,000
Reduction in the estate's value£30,000
Inheritance tax at 40% on that reduction£12,000 potentially reclaimable

The traps in the relief

The relief is valuable, but it is not simply a refund of the difference. HMRC's manual lists several reasons a claim can work out worse than expected, and once made it cannot be withdrawn.

  • Every sale counts. A claim covers every interest in land the executors sell, in the same capacity, within the three years. If they sell a second property or a piece of land for more than its probate value, that gain is set against the loss.
  • Selling costs are ignored. The figure used is the gross price. Agent's commission, legal fees and the like are not deducted, so the "loss" is smaller than the cash the estate actually lost.
  • The price must be the best reasonably obtainable. If HMRC thinks the home was sold too cheaply, for example to the first offer without proper marketing, it can ask the Valuation Office what the best price at the time would have been, and use that instead.
  • Sales to family do not qualify. A sale to anyone who has been entitled to the property under the will or intestacy, or to their spouse, civil partner, child or grandchild, is excluded.
  • Buying land undoes it. If the executors buy land in the same capacity between the death and four months after the last sale, the relief is reduced or lost.
  • Changes are adjusted for. If the home was damaged or improved between the death and the sale, the sale price is adjusted so that the relief reflects the market, not what happened to the building. A loss caused by vandalism or neglect while the home stood empty is usually not relieved.
  • Joint ownership can backfire. Where the person owned a share, the probate value of the share may have been discounted. The relief uses a plain share of the gross sale price, with no discount, which can wipe out the loss or even increase the tax.

It also affects capital gains tax: once the sale price replaces the probate value, it becomes the base cost too, so there is no separate capital gains loss on the same sale. For these reasons, a claim is usually worth working through with the solicitor or accountant before it is sent, not after.

How HMRC and the Valuation Office check the figures

GOV.UK says the Valuation Office "may contact you about the valuations you've provided", and HMRC's manual notes that most land in the UK that is chargeable to tax on a death is referred to it. In practice, a referral usually happens in one of three ways.

  1. When the inheritance tax account is filed. The valuer compares the figure with sales from around the date of death. Figures that look right are often accepted with little exchange; others lead to questions or an inspection.
  2. When a sale is reported. A sale on IHT405, a corrective account or an IHT38 claim puts a second figure next to the first. The bigger the gap and the shorter the time between them, the more likely it is to be looked at.
  3. When capital gains tax is reported. A large gain on an inherited home can lead HMRC to question the date-of-death value, particularly where it was never checked for inheritance tax.

When a valuer at the Valuation Office looks at a probate figure, they are asking the same questions any valuer would. What sold nearby at the time? How does the home compare? What condition was it in? Was there anything a buyer would have paid extra for, such as a large garden or development potential? If the executors' figure comes with the answers already set out, the conversation is short. If it is a number on a form, the executors have to rebuild the reasoning after the event.

Chris Bloor, on site

Twice now I have been asked to look back at a probate figure after the sale came in high, and both times the question was the same: what did the garden or the plot add. A neighbour buying the land next door isn't the open market, and a developer paying for potential isn't either. If you think there's development value, say so at the start. Note it on the day, with the land it sits on measured. Far easier to set that out when the home is in front of you than to reconstruct it from a sale that puzzled everyone afterwards.

Chris Bloor

Why a well-evidenced date-of-death value protects executors

Executors sign the inheritance tax account and are responsible for the values on it. When a sale price later differs, a good date-of-death valuation does three things.

  • It shows the figure was right on the day. Comparable sales from the time are the evidence the Valuation Office will look at anyway.
  • It explains the gap. If the valuation records the condition at the date of death, damage while the home stood empty or work done before the sale is easy to show.
  • It shows reasonable care. HMRC can add a penalty where an inaccurate figure was put forward carelessly. Relying on an informed valuation from a qualified, independent valuer is a very different position from relying on a guess.

That is why the probate valuation is worth getting right at the start, even where the home is about to be sold. The figure sets the inheritance tax now and the capital gains tax later, and the existing guide to what HMRC expects explains the basis it is prepared on.

Frequently asked questions

Can HMRC use the sale price instead of our probate valuation?

Often, if the sale was soon after the death, on the open market and to an unconnected buyer. HMRC's form asks whether you want to use it, and the Valuation Office may compare the two even if you do not.

We sold for less than probate value but paid no inheritance tax. Can we claim anything?

Not under IHT38, because there is no inheritance tax to reclaim. Selling for less than the date-of-death value may instead give a capital loss for capital gains tax, which the seller can normally only set against their own gains.

Does the four-year limit run from the grant of probate?

No. It runs from the date of death. Sales in the first three years count either way; sales in the fourth year count only if they are at a loss.

Should we wait to claim until everything is sold?

Often, yes. A claim covers every sale of land within the period, and it cannot be withdrawn, so an early claim can be undone by a later sale at a gain. Your adviser will weigh up when to claim.

Do we need a new valuation if the house sells for more?

Not usually. The sale itself is evidence. What helps is the original valuation, with the comparable sales and condition at the date of death, so the difference can be explained.

Getting the figure right first

If the estate includes a home, the cheapest time to protect the executors is before the forms are filed. Our RICS valuations are prepared to the standards in our complete guide to RICS valuations, and you can check recent sold prices yourself with the house price tool. When you are ready, ask for a fixed price.

Need a survey on a specific property?

Tell us the address and we will send a fixed price in writing, with no obligation.

Get your fixed quote