CJ Bloor Property Consultants0333 577 9556Call the officeGet a fixed quoteGet a quote
Advice

Help to Buy Valuation Too High or Too Low? What You Can Do

Why a Help to Buy valuation can come in higher or lower than you expected, how your improvements and alterations are treated, when the administrator rejects a report, and how to challenge a figure you think is wrong.

Spacious kitchen with modern cabinetry and large windows for ample natural light.

When the Help to Buy valuation arrives, most people look at one number and react to it. If it is higher than expected, the repayment feels unfair. If it is lower, it can feel like good news, until you learn the administrator may not accept it.

This guide explains why a Help to Buy valuation can come in higher or lower than you expected, what the administrator does with a figure it thinks is out of line, how your improvements are treated, and what you can sensibly do if you think the number is wrong. It covers equity loans in England and is written from the valuer's side of the process. It is not financial or legal advice.

Why the figure cuts both ways

You repay the same percentage of today's value as the percentage you borrowed, which is how the loan was designed from the start, as the Help to Buy scheme explained sets out. So the valuation does not just inform the repayment, it sets it.

An illustration, not a real case:

LoanValued at £270,000Valued at £280,000Valued at £290,000
20% loan (most of England)£54,000£56,000£58,000
40% loan (London)£108,000£112,000£116,000

Interest owed, fees and any arrears are added on top. The table shows why people care about every few thousand pounds, and also why the administrator checks every report against the evidence: it is lending public money, and a figure that is too low costs the taxpayer in the same way a figure that is too high costs you.

What the valuer is actually valuing

The valuer gives the Market Value of your home as it stands on the day of the inspection. In RICS terms that is broadly the price a willing buyer and a willing seller would agree, after the home has been properly marketed, with both acting knowledgeably and neither under pressure. GOV.UK describes the same thing more simply: a value based on the property's condition and the current housing market.

Three things follow from that definition:

  • It is not the price you paid. That was a price for a new home, at a point in time, often with a developer's incentives built in.
  • It is not an asking price. Homes are often marketed above what they eventually sell for.
  • It is the home as it is. A defect, an unfinished job or a missing certificate is reflected, just as a buyer's surveyor would reflect it.

To support the figure, the administrator requires at least three sales of like-for-like homes, of the same type, size and age, within two miles and the last 12 months, with commentary explaining how they justify the value. Those sales are the heart of the report, and they are where any challenge has to start.

Why your number and the valuer's differ

When an owner's expectation and the valuation are far apart, it usually comes down to one of a handful of reasons.

ReasonWhat is going on
The new-build premiumA new home often sells for more than the same home will fetch second-hand. The valuation compares your home with what similar homes have actually sold for, which can be below the price you paid even if local prices have risen
Asking pricesThe figures on property portals are what sellers hope for. The valuer works from sold prices
Online estimatesAutomated estimates work from averages and cannot see inside your home, its condition or its exact position on the estate
Different homes on the same estateA detached house on a corner plot and a mid-terrace on the main road are not like-for-like, even with the same number of bedrooms
Developer incentives nearbyIf new homes are still being sold close by with paid deposits, stamp duty or extras thrown in, the headline prices overstate what buyers really paid
The market has movedA sale from eleven months ago may not reflect today, in either direction

The new-build premium is the one that surprises people most. It means a Help to Buy home can be valued at, or a little below, the price paid several years earlier, without anything having gone wrong with the home or the market.

Chris Bloor, on site

The new-build premium catches nearly everyone. I valued a home on an estate once where the owner had paid a good deal more than I could stand up against the second-hand sales nearby, and the first question in the hallway was whether something had gone wrong. Nothing had. A new home carries a premium the day you buy it, much like a car off the forecourt, and the figure I give is what a buyer would pay for it now, as it stands. So a valuation at or just below your original price is not a mistake. It is the market being honest with you.

Chris Bloor

How your improvements are treated

This is where many owners are caught out, because the rules depend on what you did and whether you asked first. They come from GOV.UK's guidance on structural alterations to a Help to Buy home.

What you didDo you need permission?Effect on the repayment
Redecorated, carpeted, landscaped the gardenNoCounts in the value as it stands
Refitted the existing kitchen or bathroom, built-in furnitureNoCounts in the value as it stands
Structural work with the administrator's permission, paid for yourselfYesAny increase in value from it is left out of the repayment
Structural work with permission, paid for by a grantYesThe increase is included
Structural work without permissionYes, and it was not soughtThe increase is included, so you repay a share of it

Structural work includes anything needing planning permission, an extension or conservatory, a loft or basement conversion, and changes to the layout such as knocking two rooms into one. GOV.UK says permission is only given for medical reasons.

Two practical points. First, if you were given permission, tell the valuer and send the permission letter, so the report can show the value with and without the work. Second, if you made structural changes without permission, GOV.UK says you can still apply retrospectively and must complete a declaration of the work, even if the application is refused. Tell the administrator before the valuation, not after, because a report that has to be redone is at your cost.

What the administrator checks

GOV.UK gives two grounds for rejecting a valuation report:

  • it does not follow the criteria, for example the valuer is not independent, did not inspect inside, or used too few or unsuitable sales (our guide to Help to Buy valuation costs covers who can carry one out)
  • the figure is too high or low compared with similar properties

If the report is rejected, you have to provide and pay for a new one. That is why a figure shaded down to please the owner is a false economy. It may save money on paper, but if it does not stand up against the sales evidence, the likely result is a second fee and a delay, with the three-month validity of the first report wasted.

If you think the valuation is too high

Start with the report, not the number. A good report shows every comparable it relies on, what each sold for, when, how far away it is, and how the valuer adjusted it to your home.

Then work through it:

  1. Check the facts about your home. Floor area, number of bedrooms, parking, garden, tenure, and anything about condition. A factual error is the strongest ground for a change.
  2. Check the comparables. Are they genuinely like-for-like? A larger house type, a better plot or a sale with obvious extras may have been given too much weight.
  3. Find better evidence if it exists. Look for sold prices, not asking prices, of homes of the same type, size and age, within two miles and the last 12 months. HM Land Registry's price paid data is the starting point; the sale needs to be completed and registered to count.
  4. Send it to the valuer in writing. Explain briefly why each sale is a better match. A valuer should consider any relevant evidence you send, and respond.
  5. Accept that the figure changes only if the evidence supports it. A valuer who moves a figure without evidence is putting both of you at risk of rejection.

If you remain unhappy with how the valuation was carried out, every RICS-regulated firm must have a complaints procedure, and you can ask for it. A complaint is about how the work was done, though, not a way to negotiate the number.

Chris Bloor, on site

When a figure looks too high, the instinct is to argue the number itself. Don't. Go to the comparables at the back of the report and read them properly. I've had owners come back with an asking price from a portal, or a neighbour's house that sounded the same but sat on a bigger plot, and neither shifts anything. What does shift a figure is a completed sale, same house type, close by, recent, that the valuer hadn't picked up. Bring that and it gets looked at. Bring a hope and it won't. The evidence moves the number, nothing else does.

Chris Bloor

Can I just get a second valuation?

GOV.UK does not stop you instructing a different RICS valuer, but you pay again, and the administrator applies the same checks to every report. If the first figure was well supported, a second valuer looking at the same sales is likely to reach a similar view. Where a second opinion does help is where you have good reason to think the first report got the facts or the comparables wrong.

Should I wait for a better market?

You can, but the valuation follows the market in both directions, and interest keeps running from year six, rising every April. Waiting is a bet on prices, not a way round the valuation, and it is a decision for you and your adviser.

If you think the valuation is too low

If you are paying off the loan from savings or a remortgage, a low figure saves you money only if it is accepted. If it is out of line with similar sales, the administrator can reject it, and you are back to paying for a new report. If you think the figure is lower than the evidence supports, it is worth saying so before you send it.

If you are selling, a low valuation makes little difference to what you repay. When you sell, you repay your share of the market value or the agreed sale price, whichever is higher. The guide to paying off a Help to Buy loan step by step covers how that works through the sale, and what to do if a buyer's survey leads to a lower price, and our guide to selling a Help to Buy home covers the wider sale.

A low figure can also matter for your remortgage. Your new lender values the home separately, for its own purposes, and the two figures do not have to agree. If the lender's figure is lower than the Help to Buy valuation, your new loan may not cover the full redemption, so speak to your mortgage adviser early.

Getting a figure that stands up

Most disputes about a Help to Buy valuation can be avoided at the inspection. A few things help:

  • Tell the valuer about anything that affects the value, good or bad: a refitted kitchen, a new boiler, a defect you know about, a missing certificate.
  • Have the paperwork ready: permission letters for structural work, building control certificates, and any notes about service charges if you own a flat.
  • Point out recent sales you know about on the estate, especially of your house type. The valuer will check them, and it is far easier to consider them before the report is written than after.
  • Make sure the valuer can see every room. A report that has to assume what it could not see is harder to rely on.

Our guide to preparing for a home valuation covers what helps on the day and what makes no difference.

Frequently asked questions

Can I challenge a Help to Buy valuation?

Yes, by challenging the evidence. Read the comparables, check the facts about your home, and send the valuer any better sold-price evidence in writing. The figure should change only if the evidence supports a change.

Why is my valuation lower than I paid?

Often because the price you paid was for a new home, which commonly sells at a premium over the same home second-hand. The valuation compares your home with what similar homes have recently sold for, not with the developer's price.

Will my new kitchen increase what I repay?

It can. Refitting an existing kitchen or bathroom does not need permission, and it counts in the value like anything else about the home as it stands.

Does an extension increase what I repay?

If you had the administrator's permission and paid for it yourself, the increase in value from the extension is left out. If you did not have permission, the increase is included and you repay a share of it.

Does the administrator ever accept a lower figure than the valuer's?

GOV.UK describes the administrator accepting or rejecting a report, not setting its own figure. If it rejects a report as too high or too low, you need a new one.

Can I use an online estimate to argue the figure down?

Not on its own. An automated estimate cannot see your home and is not sales evidence. Sold prices of like-for-like homes nearby carry weight; estimates and asking prices do not.

A valuation you can follow

The best defence against a figure you do not trust is a report that shows its working. Our Help to Buy valuation service is prepared to the administrator's checklist by a RICS Registered Valuer independent of any agent, with every comparable set out and explained. You can ask for a fixed price before you book, and our complete guide to RICS valuations explains the standards behind every valuation.

Need a survey on a specific property?

Tell us the address and we will send a fixed price in writing, with no obligation.

Get your fixed quote