Single Joint Expert Valuation in a Divorce: How It Works
A step-by-step guide to the Single Joint Expert valuation in divorce proceedings in England and Wales: when the court directs one, how the valuer is chosen and instructed, what a good report contains, written questions within 10 days, who pays, and when a second expert is allowed.

If your divorce or separation has reached the court and the value of the home is in dispute, you will almost certainly hear the words Single Joint Expert. Our guide to how the family home is valued in a divorce explains where a Single Joint Expert fits among the other ways of reaching a figure. This guide goes further: it follows the process from choosing the valuer to questioning the report, and explains what a good report looks like.
It is written from the valuer's side, and it covers financial remedy proceedings in England and Wales, where the rules are in Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules and the practice directions that go with it. It is not legal advice. Your solicitor will advise on your own case, and the court can always direct something different.
What a Single Joint Expert is
The Family Procedure Rules define a single joint expert as a person who gives expert evidence on behalf of two or more of the parties. In a divorce, that usually means one RICS Registered Valuer instructed by both of you to value the home, or sometimes another property one of you owns. If you are new to how these reports are put together, our guide to what a RICS valuation involves is a good starting point.
Two things set this apart from a valuation for one of you:
- The duty is to the court. Rule 25.3 says it is the duty of experts to help the court on matters within their expertise, and that this duty overrides any obligation to the person who instructed or pays them. The valuer is not on either side.
- Both of you are in it together. The instructions are agreed between you, both of you are copied in on what the valuer is sent, and both of you receive the same report at the same time.
The practice direction for financial cases, PD 25D, is direct about the preference: "Wherever possible, expert evidence should be obtained from a single joint expert instructed by both or all the parties." The reason is cost and time: two valuers usually means two fees, two figures and an argument between them for the court to settle.
When the court directs one
You need the court's permission to put expert evidence before it, and the test is strict: the court must think the evidence is "necessary to assist the court to resolve the proceedings" (rule 25.4). In deciding, it looks at the issues, the questions for the expert, the effect on the timetable and the cost (rule 25.5).
In financial remedy cases, an application for permission should be made as soon as possible and no later than the first appointment, the first hearing after the financial forms (Form E) have been exchanged. The court can allow it later for good reason. PD 25D gives two examples: where you cannot decide until replies to the questionnaires on your Forms E have been considered, and where you agreed the value for the settlement meeting at court (the Financial Dispute Resolution appointment) but did not settle, and now want a formal valuation for the final hearing.
Outside cases about children, you do not need the court's permission to instruct a valuer, only to put the report before the court. So you can agree a Single Joint Expert early and ask the court to approve the arrangement at the first appointment.
Choosing the valuer
PD 25D sets out a simple sequence for agreeing who to use:
- Whoever wants to instruct a valuer sends the other a list of one or more suitable names.
- The other has 10 business days to object to any of them and, if they do, to suggest their own.
- Each of you says whether you have already consulted any of the names about the case.
If you still cannot agree, the court can choose from a list you both put forward, or decide how the valuer is to be chosen (rule 25.11).
When you are putting names forward, look for a RICS Registered Valuer who values homes like yours in your area and acts as Single Joint Expert in divorce cases, and who has no connection to either of you or to an agent who might sell the house. A valuer who has already valued the home for one of you is usually a poor choice for a joint role, however good the earlier report was, because the other side will always wonder about it.
Before the application: the questions the valuer is asked
Before the permission hearing, the valuer is given the basic facts and asked to confirm a few things, so the judge has what is needed to make an order. PD 25D and PD 25B set out both sides of the exchange.
| What you tell the valuer | What the valuer confirms |
|---|---|
| The nature of the case and the issues | That the work is within their expertise |
| The questions they will be asked | That there is no conflict of interest |
| How much reading there will be | That they can do the work within the timetable |
| The likely timetable and when the report is needed | The dates to avoid, and the notice needed for a hearing |
| Any hearing date when they might give evidence | The cost, on an hourly or other basis |
| Whether either of you has public funding | Anything about being named in a public judgment |
Before applying, you should also have agreed in what proportion the fee is to be shared, at least to begin with, and when it is to be paid. The application itself must set out the valuer's qualifications, availability and timetable, who is responsible for the instructions, the likely cost and the proposed split of the fee.
The letter of instruction
Once the court gives permission, the party responsible for the instructions has 5 business days to prepare, file and serve the letter of instruction (PD 25D, paragraph 4.1). For a Single Joint Expert, the letter is agreed between you. If you cannot agree it, either of you can ask the court in writing, copied to the other, and the court will settle the letter itself, usually without a hearing (rule 25.12).
The letter does most of the work: a vague one produces a report that answers a question nobody quite asked. For a valuation, it normally covers:
- The context. That this is a financial remedy case, and the issues the value relates to.
- The questions. Usually the Market Value of the home with vacant possession at the date of inspection. Sometimes also a value at an earlier date, a value on a stated assumption, or the rental value. Each question needs to be within the valuer's expertise, clear, and limited to what the court has asked for.
- The documents. An agreed list of essential reading, with copies of the practice directions the valuer must follow.
- The people. Who lives at the property, how access will be arranged, and that the valuer may speak to either of you provided an accurate record is kept.
- The fee. How much, when it is paid, and any limit on what can be charged.
The questions are where things most often go wrong. "What is the property worth?" leaves the valuer guessing about the date and the basis. "What would the property be worth if the extension had not been built?" is a special assumption, and it is better agreed and worded in the letter than argued about once the report is out.
Bear in mind that the instructions are not privileged, so the court can see them (rule 25.14).
Chris Bloor, on siteThe letter of instruction is where I see most joint valuations go right or wrong, and it is settled before I ever walk through the door. I have had two cases where the wording asked for a value on different assumptions without saying so, and the figures looked miles apart for no good reason. If one of you wants the house valued as if an extension were never built, say that plainly in the letter, with a date attached. Agree it between you first. Once I am standing in the hallway with the instruction in my hand, that is the question I answer, not the one you wish you had asked.
The inspection, and talking to the valuer
The valuer arranges access, usually with whoever lives in the home, and keeps both of you informed of the date. On a joint instruction, it is good practice for anything one of you sends the valuer to be copied to the other, and for the valuer not to discuss the figure with one of you alone, on the day or afterwards.
That does not mean you cannot speak. If you know something the valuer needs, such as a missing building regulations certificate, put it in writing, copied to the other side, or send it through your solicitors. Information like that is far more useful at the start than as a complaint once the report is out. Our guide to preparing for a valuation visit lists the paperwork worth having ready.
What a good Single Joint Expert report looks like
PD 25B sets out what an expert's report must contain, and RICS has its own professional standard for members acting as expert witnesses. A new edition of that standard takes effect on 30 November 2026 and, among other things, says members must not use pre-populated templates or copy reports prepared by others. Put together, a good report usually shows the following.
| What to look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Addressed to the court | The duty runs to the court, not to either of you |
| The valuer's qualifications and relevant experience | So the court can judge the weight of the opinion |
| The instructions, and the facts relied on | So you can see what question was answered |
| Who inspected, and when | The value is taken at a date, and the inspection supports it |
| The comparable sales, with the adjustments explained | This is the evidence; the figure follows from it |
| Any assumptions, stated plainly | A figure on an assumption is a different figure |
| Where opinion could differ, the range and the reasons | Shows the valuer has weighed both sides |
| A summary of conclusions | The answer to each question in the letter |
| Conflict of interest statement | Confirms independence, and flags anything to disclose |
| Statement of duty to the court and a statement of truth | Required by rule 25.14 and PD 25B |
The comparables are the heart of it. Our guide to comparable evidence explains how valuers choose and adjust them, and you can check recorded sold prices yourself with our sold prices tool. A report that gives a figure without showing how the evidence leads to it is much harder for either of you, or the judge, to rely on.
Written questions to the valuer
Once the report is served, either of you can put written questions to the valuer about it. Rule 25.10 sets the limits. Unless the court directs otherwise, written questions:
- must be proportionate;
- may be put once only;
- must be put within 10 days, beginning with the date the report was served;
- must be only to clarify the report; and
- must be copied to the other side at the same time as they go to the valuer.
The answers are given within the court's timetable and are treated as part of the report.
Ten days goes quickly, and you only get one round, so read the report as soon as it arrives and agree the questions with your solicitor. Good questions point to something specific in the report and ask the valuer to explain or consider it.
| Questions that usually help | Questions that usually do not |
|---|---|
| "Did you consider the sale of 14 Elm Road in March? If so, why was it not used?" | "Why is your figure so low?" |
| "Please explain the adjustment made to comparable B for the garage." | "Please revalue the property." |
| "Does the value assume the loft conversion has building regulations approval?" | Ten pages of questions on every line of the report |
| "Would your opinion change if the boundary dispute were resolved?" | Questions about matters outside the valuer's expertise |
A question that is really an argument, or a request for a new valuation, is unlikely to get you far.
Chris Bloor, on siteOn the day itself, keep it to the house. I have arrived to find one of you waiting to walk me round and tell me, quietly, what the other has let slide. I understand why, but I can't act on it unless it is in writing and the other side has seen it too. So show me the rooms, point out the new boiler or the damp patch, and leave the history of the marriage out of it. The comparables don't care who left, and neither, on the day, can I.
Who pays
The court can give directions about the fee and can cap it before the valuer is instructed (rule 25.12). In practice, you will usually have agreed the split before the application, often half each, and the order records it.
One rule is worth understanding before you sign anything. Unless the court directs otherwise, the parties who instruct a Single Joint Expert are jointly and severally liable for the fee. In plain terms, if one of you does not pay their share, the valuer can ask the other for the whole amount, leaving you to recover it from your former partner.
Ask at the start what the fee covers. Answering written questions, updating the report before a final hearing and attending court are often charged separately, and it is better to know that before the questions are sent.
If you are still unhappy: a second expert
If the written questions do not resolve your concerns, you can ask the court for permission to rely on a valuer of your own as well. It is not automatic. The same test applies as for the first expert, so the court must think the second report is necessary, and it will weigh the cost and the delay to both of you.
In practice, the court will want a reason rooted in the report, for example a material fact the valuer did not know, comparables that are clearly not like for like, or an error in method. On a family home, the difference often costs more to argue about than it is worth, and your solicitor can tell you whether an application is realistic.
Some people pay a valuer privately to review the Single Joint Expert's report and help them frame their written questions. That review is advice to you, not evidence: it cannot be put before the court without permission. If the court does allow a second expert, it can direct the two valuers to discuss the case and produce a statement of what they agree and disagree on (rule 25.16).
Before the final hearing
A valuation speaks at its date. If months have passed or the market has moved, the court may want an update, and it is usually quicker and cheaper for the same valuer to update their own report than to start again.
The expert's evidence is normally given in writing. The court will only direct the valuer to attend a hearing if that is necessary in the interests of justice (rule 25.9), so in most cases the report and the answers to questions are the whole of the valuer's evidence.
Frequently asked questions
Can we use a Single Joint Expert without going to court?
Yes, in effect. If you instruct one valuer jointly for mediation or a negotiated settlement, the valuer can prepare the report on the same footing, with an agreed letter, a copy to each of you and a statement of independence. Strictly, it becomes a Part 25 report only if the court later gives permission for it to be used, so tell the valuer at the start if that is likely.
Can one of us speak to the valuer privately?
You can give the valuer factual information, but on a joint instruction anything material should be in writing and copied to the other side. A valuer acting jointly should not discuss the figure with one of you alone.
Is the Single Joint Expert's figure final?
No. It is evidence, and usually very important evidence, but the judge decides the case. In practice, a well-reasoned figure that has survived written questions is rarely departed from without good reason.
Getting the instruction right
Most of the value of a Single Joint Expert report is decided before anyone visits the house: by choosing a suitable valuer and by asking clear questions in the letter. If you need one, our divorce valuation service covers valuations as Single Joint Expert for the court, as well as joint valuations for mediation and valuations for one of you. Our complete guide to RICS valuations explains the standards behind every report, and you can ask for a fixed price for your case before you decide.
More on advice
Underinsurance and the Average Clause: How a Low Rebuild Figure Cuts a Claim
What underinsurance is, how the average clause scales down a buildings insurance claim with a worked example, how insurers check your rebuild figure after a claim, what index-linking and day one cover do, and what freeholders and leaseholders in blocks of flats need to know.
ReadStaircasing Shared Ownership: How the Valuation Sets the Price of Your Next Share
How the price of a further share in a shared ownership home is worked out: today's value not the original price, old and 2021 model leases, 1% staircasing, why the landlord needs a RICS valuation, improvements and disrepair left out, final staircasing, and what you can do if the valuation looks high.
ReadRebuild Cost of a House: How It Is Worked Out and Why It Is Not the Market Value
What the rebuild cost of a house is, why it can be higher or lower than the market value, what goes into the figure, how to measure your home for the free BCIS calculator, and when a surveyor's assessment is worth paying for.
ReadNeed a survey on a specific property?
Tell us the address and we will send a fixed price in writing, with no obligation.
Get your fixed quote