Underinsurance and the Average Clause: How a Low Rebuild Figure Cuts a Claim
What underinsurance is, how the average clause scales down a buildings insurance claim with a worked example, how insurers check your rebuild figure after a claim, what index-linking and day one cover do, and what freeholders and leaseholders in blocks of flats need to know.

Most people only find out whether their buildings insurance is set correctly when they make a claim. By then the figure cannot be changed, and if it was too low, the payment can be cut even for damage that has nothing to do with the cost of rebuilding the whole house.
This guide explains what underinsurance is, how the average clause works with a worked example, how insurers check your figure after a claim, what day one cover and index-linking do and do not protect you from, and what freeholders and leaseholders in blocks of flats need to know. It is general information, not legal or insurance advice: how your own policy works depends on its wording, so read it or ask your broker.
What underinsurance means
Buildings insurance is normally arranged on a reinstatement basis: if the home is damaged, the insurer pays to put it back. The sum insured is the most it will pay, and it should match the full cost of rebuilding the home from scratch, including demolition and professional fees.
You are underinsured when the sum insured is lower than that rebuild cost. It usually happens in one of four ways:
- The starting figure was a guess. It came from the purchase price, the market value, a neighbour's figure or a rule of thumb rather than a measured rebuild cost.
- The figure was carried forward for years. Building costs have risen sharply since 2021. BCIS reports that its house rebuilding cost index, run with the Association of British Insurers, rose 3.8% in 2025 alone.
- The home has changed. An extension, a loft conversion, a garage or a new natural slate roof all add to the rebuild cost, and none of them moves an index.
- The building is not standard. Stone walls, period detail, listed status and unusual construction cost more to put back than an online calculator assumes. If you are not sure, you can check whether your home is listed in a minute.
How the average clause works
Many buildings policies include a condition called average. If the sum insured is less than the rebuild cost at the time of the loss, the insurer pays only the same proportion of the claim.
The sum is simple:
Claim paid = claim × (sum insured ÷ true rebuild cost)
The key point is that it applies to partial losses. A home insured for three quarters of its rebuild cost gets three quarters of a kitchen fire claim, even though the damage is a fraction of the sum insured.
An illustration, not real figures:
| Figure | |
|---|---|
| True rebuild cost at the time of the claim | £320,000 |
| Sum insured on the policy | £240,000 |
| Proportion insured | 75% |
| Kitchen fire: cost of repairs | £40,000 |
| Paid after average (75% of £40,000) | £30,000 |
| Left for the owner to fund | £10,000 |
| If the house were destroyed: most the policy pays | £240,000, leaving £80,000 short |
The excess comes off as well, so the gap in practice is a little wider.
The 85% condition
Some policies allow a margin before average bites. RICS guidance notes that insurers have often accepted a margin of 15%, written into the policy as an "85% average condition": the claim is paid in full as long as the sum insured is at least 85% of the true rebuild cost at the time of loss.
On the figures above, a sum insured of £280,000 (87.5%) would see the £40,000 claim paid in full. A sum insured of £260,000 (81%) would not, and once the sum insured falls below the threshold, average is usually applied to the whole shortfall, not just the part below 85%. The margin helps with a partial loss. It does nothing for a total loss, where the policy still pays no more than the sum insured.
Chris Bloor, on siteMost of the underinsurance I see started as a sensible-looking number that nobody went back to. A buyer rang me once after a kitchen flood, puzzled that the payout had been cut when the fire was nowhere near the rest of the house. That is the part people miss. The clause bites on small claims too, not just a burnt-out shell. When I measure a home for a rebuild figure I am counting the extension and the converted loft, because the loss adjuster will. Carry an old figure forward long enough and it quietly becomes the wrong one.
Average is not the only way a claim can be reduced
Not every home policy has an average clause, and an insurer that finds you underinsured may look at the problem differently.
For consumers, the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 says that if you carelessly give the insurer wrong information, and it would still have insured you but for a higher premium, it can reduce a claim in proportion. If it would have charged £500 rather than the £400 you paid, it pays 80% of the claim. Where the insurer asked you for a rebuild figure and yours was carelessly low, this is the route it may take.
The two approaches can produce very different results. The Financial Ombudsman Service has published a case in which a homeowner put down a rebuild cost of £400,000, based on what a neighbour had paid for their house, when the loss adjuster put it at about £800,000. The insurer applied average and offered 50% of an escape of water claim. The ombudsman agreed the homeowner was underinsured, because the question had been clear and the insurer had pointed to an online calculator, but decided the settlement should reflect the premium the insurer would have charged instead. That came to 85% of the claim.
| Average clause | Premium-based reduction | |
|---|---|---|
| Based on | Sum insured ÷ true rebuild cost | Premium paid ÷ premium that should have been charged |
| Where it comes from | The policy wording | The 2012 Act, for consumers who were careless |
| Size of the cut | Follows the gap in the rebuild figure | Follows how much more the insurer would have charged |
If the information was given deliberately or recklessly wrong, the insurer may be able to refuse the claim altogether.
If an insurer reduces your claim for underinsurance, ask which method it has used and why. You can complain to the insurer and, if you are not satisfied, take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service. Neither route helps after a total loss, though: the policy still will not pay more than the sum insured.
How insurers check the figure after a claim
Insurers do not normally inspect a home when the policy is taken out; they rely on the figure you give them. The check usually comes when something goes wrong.
For anything beyond a small claim, the insurer normally sends a loss adjuster. As well as looking at the damage, the adjuster may measure the home, note how it is built and its finishes, and work out a rebuild cost of their own, often using BCIS data or the insurer's own costing system. That figure is then compared with the sum insured on the day of the loss, after any index-linking.
What this means for you:
- The comparison uses today's costs, not the year you bought. A figure that was right five years ago can be well short now.
- The adjuster measures what is there. An extension or converted loft you never told the insurer about is counted.
- Your evidence matters. A recent, measured reinstatement cost assessment, with the floor areas and the basis of the figure, is the strongest answer to a challenge. A figure you can show was reasonably worked out is also much harder to treat as careless.
Index-linking and day one cover
Index-linking
Most home policies increase the sum insured at each renewal in line with a building cost index. RICS guidance points out that it is not always clear what is being indexed and when: in some policies it is the sum insured at renewal, in others the indexing only starts from the date of a loss.
Index-linking is useful, but it has three limits:
- it carries forward whatever figure you started with, so a wrong figure stays wrong;
- it follows average costs across many house types, not the cost of your home;
- it knows nothing about alterations.
Day one reinstatement
Blocks of flats, larger properties and most commercial buildings are often insured on a day one basis. The sum insured has two parts:
- a declared value: the cost of rebuilding at the start of the policy year, with no allowance for inflation;
- an inflation provision or uplift: a percentage on top, chosen to cover cost increases during the policy year and the time it would take to design, get approvals for and rebuild the building. RICS guidance says uplifts commonly range from 15% to 50%.
The uplift is not spare cover for a low figure. Premiums, and average, are normally based on the declared value. If the declared value is too low, average can still apply, however generous the uplift.
An illustration, not a real case:
| Figure | |
|---|---|
| Declared value on the policy | £3,000,000 |
| Uplift chosen | 30% |
| Most the policy will pay | £3,900,000 |
| True day one rebuild cost, found after a claim | £3,600,000 |
| Declared value as a share of the true cost | 83% |
| A £300,000 claim could be paid at | about £250,000 |
Blocks of flats: freeholders and leaseholders
A block of flats is normally insured as one building, by the freeholder, a residents' management company or a right to manage company, because the lease requires it. Each leaseholder pays a share of the premium through the service charge. Leaseholders insure their own contents, not the structure.
This changes the stakes. If the block is underinsured and average is applied, the shortfall falls on whoever has to pay for the repairs, which under most leases is all the leaseholders through the service charge. A fire in one flat can become a bill for every flat in the building.
If you run the block as a freeholder, director of a management company or managing agent:
- check what the lease says about the basis of cover; many require insurance for the full reinstatement cost;
- have the block assessed as a whole, including the common parts, lifts, bin stores, car parks, boundary walls and external works; if there are no reliable floor plans, a measured building survey gives you a record to work from for every future assessment;
- keep the assessment on file and repeat it on the RICS cycle, because you may have to show leaseholders and the insurer how the figure was set.
If you are a leaseholder:
- Since 31 December 2023, the Financial Conduct Authority's rules for multi-occupancy buildings insurance require insurers and brokers to give leaseholders key information about the policy, including the sum insured for the building, a breakdown of the premium and the commission paid. You can ask for it directly if it does not reach you.
- Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, a leaseholder who pays towards the insurance through a service charge can ask the landlord in writing for a summary of the insurance, including the sum insured, and the landlord has 21 days to reply. These rights are being reformed by the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024, so check the current position before relying on the detail.
- Compare the sum insured with the size of the block. If it has not changed in years, or looks low for the number of flats, ask how it was worked out and when it was last assessed.
Chris Bloor, on siteIn a block the figure is not just the freeholder's problem. I looked at a converted Victorian house last year, three flats, one policy, and the leaseholder buying the top one had no idea the sum insured even existed. He was paying his share through the service charge and assumed someone had checked it. Nobody had. Ask for the rebuild figure before you commit, and ask when it was last assessed rather than last index-linked. The two are not the same, and the gap tends to land on everyone's service charge at once.
Houses converted into flats
A house split into two or three flats is a common trap. Sometimes each flat owner insures "their" flat separately, with different insurers and different figures. A fire or a roof failure does not respect the boundary between flats, and separate policies can leave the shared structure, the roof and the foundations with no clear cover or a much lower figure than the building needs. The lease usually says who must insure what. If it says the building is insured as a whole, it should be, on a figure for the whole building.
How often to reassess
RICS guidance on reinstatement cost assessments recommends an annual adjustment for inflation and a full review and reassessment every three years, or earlier if the property is significantly altered. In practice it is also worth checking the figure:
- after an extension, loft conversion, conservatory, garage or outbuilding;
- after work that changes how the home is built, such as a new roof covering or replacement windows in a better material;
- when you buy, remortgage or change insurer, so an old figure is not carried forward (our guide on when to arrange a property valuation covers the other points at which a professional figure is worth having);
- for a block, whenever a major works project changes the building, such as new cladding, balconies or a lift.
The figure in your mortgage valuation is a quick estimate made for the lender, and our guide to the difference between a survey and a mortgage valuation explains its limits. It is not a substitute for a measured assessment if your home is larger, older or unusual, or if you insure a block.
Frequently asked questions
Does the average clause apply to small claims?
Yes, where the policy has one. That is its main effect. Average scales every claim by the proportion you are underinsured, so a small claim is reduced in the same proportion as a large one.
Does every home insurance policy have an average clause?
No. Some policies use average, some rely on the premium-based approach allowed under consumer insurance law, and some do not ask for a rebuild figure at all and cover up to a fixed limit instead. If yours has a fixed limit, check it is comfortably above your rebuild cost.
Can I just insure for a much higher figure to be safe?
You can, but you pay a premium on cover a claim could never use. The policy pays what it actually costs to rebuild, not the sum insured. A measured figure avoids both problems.
I am a leaseholder. Can I insure my own flat to be safe?
Usually not. The lease normally requires the building to be insured as a whole by the freeholder or management company, and a separate policy on your flat may not respond to damage to the structure. Ask for the insurance details and raise any concern about the sum insured with whoever arranges the cover.
Who pays if a block of flats turns out to be underinsured?
It depends on the lease and on why it was underinsured. Often the shortfall is passed to leaseholders through the service charge. If the freeholder failed to insure as the lease required, leaseholders may have a claim against them; that needs legal advice.
Getting the figure right
The cheapest time to find out your sum insured is wrong is before a claim. For a standard house, the free BCIS calculator and a careful measurement are a sensible check. For an older, larger or altered house or bungalow, our reinstatement cost assessments give a measured figure, with the floor areas and the basis set out so you can show your insurer how it was reached. We do not assess blocks of flats, or listed or non-traditional homes. You can ask for a fixed price, and our complete guide to RICS valuations explains the other valuations we carry out.
More on advice
Staircasing Shared Ownership: How the Valuation Sets the Price of Your Next Share
How the price of a further share in a shared ownership home is worked out: today's value not the original price, old and 2021 model leases, 1% staircasing, why the landlord needs a RICS valuation, improvements and disrepair left out, final staircasing, and what you can do if the valuation looks high.
ReadRebuild Cost of a House: How It Is Worked Out and Why It Is Not the Market Value
What the rebuild cost of a house is, why it can be higher or lower than the market value, what goes into the figure, how to measure your home for the free BCIS calculator, and when a surveyor's assessment is worth paying for.
ReadHouse Valuation for Divorce: How the Family Home Is Valued
How the family home is valued in a divorce or separation in England and Wales: agreed figures, agent appraisals and RICS valuations, the Single Joint Expert, what the valuer actually values, and what to do if you disagree with the figure.
ReadNeed a survey on a specific property?
Tell us the address and we will send a fixed price in writing, with no obligation.
Get your fixed quote